Performance Task Assessment List Investigating a Controversial Issue

Element	Possible Points	Earned Assessment
		Self	Teacher
The student gathers sufficient information and support materials for his/her position.
The student uses material from newspapers, magazines, news reports, and resource materials.
The student organizes the information and prepares an argument for his/her position.
Sufficient examples and details are used to support the argument.
The position/argument is clearly stated.
The student listens to, asks probing questions about, and understands the opposing position.
The student is able to state the strengths and weaknesses of each position.
The student discusses the positions/arguments with his/her opponent criticizing ideas, not the person. Listening is active and polite.
Opposing students try to reach a consensus or develop an alternative. Evidence of compromising is noted.
The student writes a 1-2 page paper and/or a letter to an editor supporting the position he/she finally supported.
Total:

©1995 Pomperaug Regional School District, Middlebury, CT
Through an agreement with the Maryland Assessment Consortium, permission is granted to Maryland Public Schools to reproduce this material for non-profit, educational use.