| Panel Group: |
Student: |
|||
| Points | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| Criteria | ||||
| Level of understanding of the subject matter demonstrated by presenter | not much at all | a minimal amount | a respectable amount | a tremendous amount |
| Logical organization of information presented | impossible to follow | difficult to follow | somewhat clear | extremely clear |
| Information presented covers all subsidiary questions or subtopics | no questions or subtopics covered | few questions or subtopics covered | most questions or subtopics covered | all questions or subtopics covered |
| Enthusiasm of presenter about the topic | not at all enthusiastic | seemed mildly interested | seemed very interested | obviously very enthusiastic |
| Level of oral communication skills exhibited by presenter | extremely poor | minimally adequate | acceptable | excellent |
| Effort reflected in presentation | hardly any at all | enough to "get by" | a respectable amount | a tremendous amount |
| Demonstration of courtesy to other panel members | extremely poor | minimally adequate | acceptable | excellent |
| Length of presentation followed time requirement | inadequate | acceptable | good | excellent |
| Responses to audience questions | inadequate | acceptable | good | excellent |
| Subtotals | ||||
|
|
||||